Narya Celebrian I'll never fall in love
again...
Registered: Sep
2002 Location: Lost and all alone Posts:
55 |
Well, if
nothing else, I guess this little brouhaha has pulled me out
of my three day funk a little...by adding a new layer of funk,
but hey, no one said life was easy. Ever. Not for a
minute.
But as we all contemplate what to do next, I
just thought I'd express some of my thoughts on the matter .
If this is more appropriate for a group e-mail discussion, I
wil be happy to move it to that - but right now I don't have
anyone's e-mail. So for now I will post it here.
I like
the idea of being a community within a larger community, and I
like the idea of it being open, but moderated. I liked being
able to pop back and forth between lit discussions (and quote
games!), some minor silliness in the Pony, the Harem, lurking
in the other character fan threads, and movie discussion. I
liked running into people I 'knew' in different places, and in
different contexts, and I absolutely loved having a 'home'
thread to return to.
But I think there is an advantage
in being a 'community within a community' for those who do NOT
consider it a home thread as well. We all know there was major
lurking going on - I myself lurked for MONTHS before joining
in. I never would have gone out looking for the Harem or a
place like it - I wouldn't have had a clue how to start
looking for it, and since I've tried to avoid the adult /
slash/ actor fic stuff, I would have given up long before
finding the Harem if it hadn't been embedded in a larger
community. It also maintains an inflow of new posters, who add
variety and spice to the discussions, and often become
permanent 'members' of the thread.
The second issue is
how open it is (i.e., do you have to register to even read
what is going on, is it part of a bigger site or its own
entity.) I hearken back to the Frodobago discussion - the
realization that there were many more out there who felt like
we do who had not yet found us. I would feel bad if we set
ourselves up in a way that prevented us being found. And of
course, while I yearn for stability today, I know that an
insular internet community that has a set number of
individuals will not grow and thrive the way a more open one
will (recognizing that growth brings pains as
well.)
And unfortunately, however you look at it, some
level of mod control is necessary - or you become susceptible
to trolls, flaming, thread hijackers, etc. - the nasties of
the internet. But there are rules, and then there are rules.
And I'm not sure if I broke the rules of KD by posting
this here. If I have, and the mods in this wonderful place
want me to delete it, I definitely will. I stayed out of the
fight in the blue place, and I have no intention of getting
into one here.
I'm just too darn sad this week. I have
no fight left in me.

__________________ Things fall apart; the center
cannot hold; mere anarchy is loosed upon the world
Report
this post to a moderator | IP: Logged |